There are differences in funding based on whether or not a state participates in Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare. The federal government provided additional funds to states undergoing Medicaid expansion, paying 100 percent of Medicaid expansion costs through 2016 and 90 percent of those costs through 2020.
All states, whether or not they participate in Medicaid expansion, continue to receive federal funding from these three sources:
Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) PaymentsFederal Medical Assistance Percentages (FMAP)Enhanced Federal Medical Assistance Percentages (eFMAP)
Disproportionate Share Hospital Payments
Medicaid is not exactly known for being generous when it comes to paying for health care. According to the American Hospital Association, hospitals are paid only 87 cents for every dollar spent by the hospital to treat people on Medicaid.
Hospitals that care for more people on Medicaid or for people that are uninsured, in the end, are reimbursed far less than facilities that operate in areas where there are more people covered by private insurance. Between 2000 and 2018, at least 85 rural hospitals closed their doors to inpatient care due to low reimbursement rates and other financial concerns.
To even out the playing field, Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) payments came into effect. Additional federal funds are given to the states to divide amongst eligible hospitals that see a disproportionate number of people with little to no insurance. The idea was to decrease the financial burden to those facilities so that they could continue to provide care to individuals with low incomes.
Different formulas are used to calculate federal DSH funding for each state. These formulas take into account the prior year’s DSH allotment, inflation, and the number of inpatient hospitalizations for people on Medicaid or who are uninsured. DSH payments cannot exceed 12% of the state’s total Medicaid medical assistance expenditures for any given year.
Federal Medical Assistance Percentages
Federal Medical Assistance Percentages (FMAP) remain the primary source of federal Medicaid funding. The concept is simple. For every $1 a state pays for Medicaid, the federal government matches it at least 100%, i.e., dollar for dollar. The more generous a state is in covering people, the more generous the federal government is required to be. There is no defined cap, and federal expenditures increase based on a state’s needs.
When you think about it, FMAP is generous but it may not exactly be fair to states that tend to have a lower average income when compared to states with higher incomes. Specifically, there may be an increased burden put on states with higher concentrations of poor people, and FMAP may give a disproportionately low reimbursement despite a state’s economic needs.
To address this issue, the Social Security Act devised a formula to calculate FMAP rates based on a state’s average income relative to the national average. While every state receives at least an FMAP of 50% (the federal government pays 50% of Medicaid costs, i.e. $1 for every $1 spent by the state), other states will receive higher percentages.
Alaska, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Virginia, Washington, and Wyoming are the only states to have an FMAP of 50% for Fiscal Year 2020 (October 1, 2019 through September 30, 2020). All other states receive a higher percentage of Medicaid funds from the federal government.
Notably, Mississippi has the lowest per capita income level with a 2020 FMAP of 76.98%. This means the federal government pays for 76.98% of the state’s Medicaid costs, contributing $3.34 for every $1 the state spends.
Enhanced Federal Medical Assistance Percentages
Enhanced matching rates are similar to FMAP but are taken one step further. They increase the percentage of costs paid by the federal government for certain services. The minimum enhanced FMAP for Fiscal Year 2020 is 76.50. The services covered by enhanced matching rates include but are not limited to:
Breast and cervical cancer treatment Family planning services Home health services Preventive services for adults
The Affordable Care Act increased the enhanced FMAP for states from October 1, 2015 through September 30, 2019. It did so by 23 percentage points but did not allow any state to exceed 100%. For Fiscal Year 2020, the enhanced matching rates will be lower. The Healthy Kids Act will allow an increase in the enhanced FMAP by 11.5%, again not to exceed 100% total.
The services covered by enhanced matching rates are seen as valuable because they may help to decrease the burden of healthcare costs in the future. In that way, paying more money upfront is seen as a worthy investment.
Healthy Adult Opportunity
The GOP aims to decrease how much federal money is spent on Medicaid. The 2020 Fiscal Year budget proposed cutting Medicaid by $1.5 trillion over the next decade but the budget failed to pass. In January 2020, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has introduced the Healthy Adult Opportunity (HAU).
This initiative will allow states to apply for Medicaid waivers that will decrease federal funding by setting caps on a subset of the Medicaid population. Specifically, adults on Medicaid expansion or adults less than 65 years old without disabilities or long-term care placement needs would be affected. Pregnant women and low-income parents would be excluded. States could require asset tests for these individuals, propose work requirements, and/or require cost-sharing. They could also change coverage for health care and prescription medications, although there are minimum requirements set by the federal government. States could benefit by sharing up to 25% to 50% in federal cost savings.
Concerns have been raised that this approach would significantly decrease the number of people covered by Medicaid and weaken a safety net for those in need. At this time, it is unknown how many states will choose to participate in the initiative.
A Word From Verywell
Let’s not forget that state governments also contribute dollars to Medicaid. How they do this varies from state to state, but how much they contribute affects how much help they get from the federal government. The fact is that neither the federal or state governments can afford to pay for Medicaid on its own. Only together can they pool enough resources to care for the millions of people in need. If cuts to Medicaid are approved, whether by block grants or per capita limits, a large segment of the population may not be able to afford the health care they need.
